January 30 , 2017:
by Pete Buchholz
Ever since their discovery, the huge back plates and tail spikes on stegosaurs have inspired wonder, but also puzzlement about their purpose.
Stegosaurs are some of the most instantly recognizable dinosaurs to the general public. They are well known for their distinctive anatomy, especially the large flat plates that covered the neck, back, and tail, the four or more large spikes at the end of the tail, and ocassionally, large spikes arising from their shoulders. New discoveries and investigations are bringing us a more detailed picture of the function of the plates and spikes whose purpose has been debated since their discovery.
Stegosaurus and its closest relatives, appropriately known as stegosaurs, were four-legged plant-eating dinosaurs that had distinctive armor made up of upright flattened plates on the neck and back and spikes on the tail. The different stegosaur species have unique sizes, shapes, and arrangement of armor, but were fairly similar to each other in most other aspects.
The first fragmentary stegosaur fossils were found in Europe and Africa in the early 19th Century, but it wasn't until the discovery of Stegosaurus itself in the United States in 1877, that their true nature was revealed. They were instant media sensations, legitimately alien reptiles that roamed primeval forests on this very planet in the incredibly distant past.
The earliest scientific and artistic reconstructions of Stegosaurus show an animal with truly bizarre proportions. It had very short forelimbs and very long hindlimbs which caused the back to slope steeply to a small head on a stubby neck. The plates were initially placed in a single row down the middle of the back, and some early reconstructions show eight spikes at the end of the tail instead of four.
Other early ideas about stegosaur plate anatomy include the idea that they in fact covered the sides of the animal like a pangolin or armadillo. Another proposal that was published (although probably as a joke) claimed that the plates were oriented horizontally and could have been used as flight surfaces for gliding off cliffs.
More nearly complete remains showed that the plates are actually in two staggered or alternating rows instead of one and that at the end of the tail there were just four spikes. The short forelimbs and long hindlimbs were still reconstructed in a way that created a steeply sloped back and a short, stubby neck.
Examination of the braincase and vertebrae of Stegosaurus revealed further surprises. It was found to have a tiny brain, and an expansion in the hip vertebrae that was commonly, but wrongly, regarded as a second brain. This gave it a reputation of having an IQ so low it needed another brain in its rear-end.
To make matters worse, not only was it nearly brainless, it was thought of as woefully under-armored, the plates offering no protection from predators, and the tail surely too heavy to swing. For much of the 20th Century, Stegosaurus the dullard was a dominant narrative about the animal. Many artistic reconstructions of the time showed carnivorous dinosaurs taking bites of hapless stegosaurs that barely seemed to notice.
Some truly exceptional specimens of Stegosaurus have been discovered in recent decades and show that although the initial anatomical descriptions were broadly correct, they got several things wrong. For instance, many early reconstructions underestimated the size of the forelimbs and placed the shoulders too far forward, incorrectly shortening the neck and forcing the head to be very close to the ground.
In reality, Stegosaurus had very muscular arms and shoulders, and with their shoulders in the right place, their necks were shown to be fairly long and flexible. The tail was also well-muscled and flexible with its spiked tip – nicknamed a "thagomizer" in a 1982 "The Far Side" cartoon – held aloft. This was true of other stegosaurs too.
New discoveries and interpretations allow paleoillustrators to create art that is both aesthetically pleasing and as scientifically accurate as possible. Use the slider to see how Earth Archives' resident paleoillustrator Julio Lacerda, has modified his August 2016 illustration of Stegosaurus stenops to better reflect the anatomy revealed by the Natural History Museum – London's “Sophie” specimen of Stegosaurus.”
Additional discoveries of stegosaurs from around the world have informed our ideas of their evolution, and the function of their armor. Stegosaurs have been found in rocks dating from the Middle Jurassic to the Early Cretaceous in North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia. Some spectacular new finds include Huayangosaurus and Gigantspinosaurus from the Middle to Late Jurassic of China, and Miragaia from the Late Jurassic of Portugal. Huayangosaurus is one of the most completely known primitive stegosaurs, Gigantspinosaurus is notable for its enormous shoulder spines, and Miragaia for its extremely long neck.
The earliest stegosaurs, like Huayangosaurus and Gigantspinosaurus, are similar in many ways to Stegosaurus itself, but their armor differs in three critical areas. First, many early stegosaurs had long (and in the case of Gigantspinosaurs, humongous) spines arising from their shoulders, a feature absent in Stegosaurus and its closest kin.
Secondly, many early stegosaurs had a larger number of tail spikes, and fewer plates. In some species there is a smooth transition between spikes and plates with armor of intermediate shape, which suggests the plates evolved from spikes that flattened over time.
Lastly, most other stegosaurs had plates arranged in pairs along the back rather than alternating from right to left. Paleontologists know that Stegosaurus's plates alternate because well preserved fossils of Stegosaurus show this. Also, all of Stegosaurus's plates are unique and there are no duplicates found. In many other stegosaurs it's common to find duplicated mirror-image plates, indicating that their plates were paired on the left and right sides.
As our understanding of stegosaur anatomy and evolution has increased, our ideas about the plates and spikes have changed. Initial ideas about the plates focused on armor as a use, although their delicate nature and placement on the back led many to doubt their usefulness.
Another popular idea focused on their possible use in warming up or cooling down their bodies. Paleontologists noted that the internal anatomy of the plates was packed with blood vessels. The high surface area and abundant blood supply may have been an effective way to heat up in the sun or cool down a breeze on a hot day. Wind tunnel tests even showed that Stegosaurus's plates could be effective at dissipating heat. Well-preserved tissue on the plates of Hesperosaurus, a close relative of Stegosaurus also from the Late Jurassic of the USA, shows that the plates were covered in keratin. This is the same material that makes up claws, horns, and beaks, and would have limited the ability to transfer heat to the environment.
According to another idea, the plates are display structures meant to attract mates. Many animals evolve strange, showy structures that serve no utility such as protection or feeding, but are used to attract mates. Examples in living animals include antlers in deer and moose, and long tail feathers in peacocks and quetzals. In other words, the main selective pressures driving the evolution of the plates may have been the quest for sexiness.
The spiked thagomizer on the other hand, has usually been regarded as a defensive weapon since their initial discovery. New discoveries and research have focused on the placement and location of the spikes, their use, as well as the flexibility of the tail.
Modeling of the range of motion in the neck and tail of Kentrosaurus, a Late Jurassic stegosaur from Tanzania, showed them to be very flexible. The tail of Kentrosaurus was so flexible its spiked tip could reach the sides of its own body. Not only could the spikes actually reach an attacker, stegosaur tail spikes often have trauma-related injuries showing that the tails were, at the very least, swung with some force.
Taken as a whole, the current understanding of stegosaur evolution and anatomy allows us to imagine the behavior of these ancient herbivores. Their plates were likely used as display structures and may have been brightly colored or boldly patterned.
The flexible spiked tails could be considered a formidable defensive weapon, able to reach the unarmored flanks. That coupled with a flexible neck that allowed the animal to look behind it and aim its tail, and the muscular forelimbs that could quickly re-position the body showed that stegosaurs were no pushovers.
Far from their former stereotype as lazy dullards, stegosaurs were like many large herbivores today, fascinating and dangerous animals.
Carpenter, Kenneth and Peter M. Galton. “Othniel Charles Marsh and the myth of the eight-spiked Stegosaurus.” In The Armored Dinosaurs, edited by Kenneth Carpenter, 76–102 . Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2001. .
Christiansen, Nicolai A., and Emanual Tschopp. "Exceptional stegosaur integument impressions from the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation of Wyoming." Swiss Journal of Geosciences 103 (2010): 163-171. doi:10.1007/s00015-010-0026-0
Czerkas, Stephen A. “A reevaluation of the plate arrangement on Stegosaurus stenops.” In Dinosaurs Past and Present, Vol 2, edited by Sylvia J. Czerkas and Everet C. Olsen, 83-99. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1987. .
Farlow, James O., Carl V. Thompson, and Daniel E. Rosner. “Plates of the Dinosaur Stegosaurus: Forced Convection Heat Loss Fins?” Science. 192 (1976): 1123-1125. .
Hone, David W. E. and Darren Naish. "The 'species recognition hypothesis' does not explain the presence and evolution of exaggerated structures in non-avialan dinosaurs.” Journal of Zoology. 290 (2013): 172–180. doi:10.1111/jzo.12035.
Maidment, Susannah C. R., David B. Norman, Paul M. Barrett, and Paul Upchurch. "Systematics and phylogeny of Stegosauria (Dinosauria: Ornithischia)." Journal of Systematic Paleontology 6 (2009): 367-407. doi:10.1017/S1477201908002459.
Maidment, Susannah C. R. and Guangbiao Wei. "A review of the Late Jurassic stegosaurs (Dinosauria, Stegosauria) from the People’s Republic of China." Geological Magazine 143 (2006): 621-634. doi:10.1017/S0016756806002500
Maidment, Susannah C. R., D. Cary Woodruff and John R. Horner. "Environmental partitioning and differential growth in species of the thyreophoran dinosaur Stegosaurus in the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation, USA" The Palaeontological Association 60th Annual Meeting Lyon: Oral Abstracts (2016): 40-41
Maidment, Susannah C. R., Charlotte Brassey, and Paul M. Barrett. "The Postcranial Skeleton of an Exceptionally Complete Individual of the Plated Dinosaur Stegosaurus stenops (Dinosauria: Thyreophora) from the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation of Wyoming, U.S.A.". PLoS ONE. 10(10) (2015): e0138352. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0138352. .
Main, Russell P., Armand de Ricqle`s, John R. Horner, and Kevin Padian. “The evolution and function of thyreophoran dinosaur scutes: implications for plate function in stegosaurs.” Paleobiology 31 (2005): 291-314. doi:https://dx.doi.org/10.1666%2F0094-8373%282005%29031%5B0291%3Ateafot%5D2.0.co%3B2.
Mallison, Heinrich. "CAD assessment of the posture and range of motion of Kentrosaurus aethiopicus HENNIG 1915." Swiss Journal of Geosciences 103 (2010): 211-233. doi:10.1007/s00015-010-0024-2
Mallison, Heinrich. “Defense Capabilities of Kentrosaurus Aethiopicus Hennig, 1915.” Palaeontologia Electronica 14(2) 10A (2011): 1-25.
McWhinney L. A., Rothschild B. M. & Carpenter K. "Posttraumatic Chronic Osteomyelitis in Stegosaurus dermal spikes". In The Armored Dinosaurs, edited by Kenneth Carpenter, 141-156. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2001.